Guidant Financial Group Blog

MarketWatch released an article on May 21, 2009 that suggested most investors should avoid self-directed IRAs. In “Why Most Investors Should Avoid Self-directed IRAs,“ Robert Powell details three main reasons:

• It is unclear who is regulating this industry;
• The IRS guidelines are complex; and
• There are very few “experts.”

While we appreciate his perspective, we do not feel it is as simple as to suggest this type of investing is only for the wealthy. We believe that individuals have the ability to make good wealth-building decisions when provided correct information.

The rules for investing in alternatives investments using retirement funds have been outlined within the Internal Revenue Code - IRC 4975. He is right – they are complex and subject to facts and circumstances. That is why you need to work with a company (not just an individual) that really understands how these rules apply to the assets you are interested in investing in. There is no space between us on this one.

But then he is also correct that there are very few experts in the field. Unfortunately, there are a lot of self-proclaimed self-directed IRA experts using social media and paid advertising to assert their position as a leader, but don’t be mislead. Do your due-diligence and involve your tax professional and investment advisor to find a firm you feel is most qualified to help you properly facilitate self-directed IRA transactions. Please consider that just because you saw them on Twitter, read a blog post about them or they have written a book does not make them an expert. Here are a couple of things to consider:

• How long have they been around?
• How many clients do they have? (If they have 2 – run!)
• How big is their company? (Size does not necessarily mean better…but it’s indication of their potential experience and strength)
• What value do they provide? (Do not shop purely based on price! If you accidentally run afoul of the rules for self-directed IRA investing, your entire IRA could be distributed. If you have a $100,000 self-directed IRA – you could be forced to take that as income, plus penalties, and pay 40-50% to the government. Saving a few hundred bucks to work with a discount provider is not a good strategy. )
• Are they registered with the Better Business Bureau and what does their history provide?
• Have they been honored, recognized or endorsed by other reputable organizations?

We have always asserted that self-directed IRAs allow people to invest in what they know and understand. It would be difficult to argue that the stock market was safer to invest in than real estate (if you know what you're doing)…especially after this year. Even spirited money man Jim Cramer recently said that real estate is a better investment than stocks today.

Self-directed IRAs allow you to decide that investments you feel are most prudent for your retirement plan. If you feel the stock market is better – buy stocks! If you like real estate…invest in that. The same goes for tax liens, private mortgages and gold. Self-directed IRAs let you invest in your core competencies and there are safe and effective ways to do it.

If you want to learn more about self-directed IRAs or real estate IRAs – contact us!